Paul
Hannum's
family
members
say
he
probably
would've
gone
to
the
hospital
earlier
if
he
had
had
health
insurance.
What all three of these
people have in common is
that they experienced
symptoms, but didn't seek
care because they were
uninsured and they worried
about the hospital expense,
according to their families.
All three died.
Research released this week
in the American Journal of
Public Health estimates that
45,000 deaths per year in
the United States are
associated with the lack of
health insurance. If a
person is uninsured, "it
means you're at mortal
risk," said one of the
authors, Dr. David
Himmelstein, an associate
professor of medicine at
Harvard Medical School.
The researchers examined
government health surveys
from more than 9,000 people
aged 17 to 64, taken from
1986-1994, and then followed
up through 2000. They
determined that the
uninsured have a 40 percent
higher risk of death than
those with private health
insurance as a result of
being unable to obtain
necessary medical care. The
researchers then
extrapolated the results to
census data from 2005 and
calculated there were 44,789
deaths associated with lack
of health insurance.
For years, Paul Hannum
didn't have health insurance
while he worked as a
freelance cameraman in
southern California.
One Sunday, Hannum
complained of a stomachache
which alarmed his pregnant
fiancée, Sarah Percy. "He
wasn't a complainer," she
said. "He's the type of guy
who, if he got a cold, he'll
power through it. I never
had known him to complain
about anything."
Hannum thought he had a
stomach flu or food
poisoning from bad chicken.
On Monday, his brother saw
him looking ashen and urged
him to go to the hospital.
"He had a little girl on the
way," his older brother
Curtis Hannum said. "He
didn't want the added burden
of an ER visit to hang on
their finances. He thought
'I'll just wait,' and he got
worse and worse."
By the time Hannum got to
the hospital and was
admitted to surgery, it was
too late.
Paul Hannum, 45, died on
Thursday, August 3, 2006,
from a ruptured appendix.
His daughter, Cameron was
born two months later.
Other studies have indicated
that the uninsured are at
greater risk of mortality
than the insured. A 2007
study from The American
Cancer Society found that
uninsured cancer patients
are 1.6 times more likely to
die within five years of
their diagnosis than those
with private insurance. In
2002, the Institute of
Medicine estimated that lack
of health insurance caused
about 18,000 deaths every
year.
The latest findings come
amid the fierce debate over
health care reform in
the U.S.
Two authors of the Harvard
study, Himmelstein and Dr.
Steffie Woolhandler are
co-founders of the
Physicians for a National
Health Program, which
supports government-backed
"single-payer" health
coverage.
The National Center for
Policy Analysis, which backs
"free-market" health care
reform, calls the Harvard
research flawed.
"The findings in this
research are based on faulty
methodology and the death
risk is significantly
overstated," said John C.
Goodman, the president of
the NCPA in a statement. But
Goodman did note there is "a
genuine crisis of the
uninsured in this country."
The lead author of the
Harvard study, Dr. Andrew
Wilper said he's confident
in his and his colleagues'
estimates. "It's consistent
with the vast body of
literature that has found
reasonably similar
findings," said Wilper,
instructor in internal
medicine at the University
of Washington. "There's
broad agreement in the
health literature regarding
this point."
Wilper said there is often
fear from those, including
his own grandmother, who
don't feel well but avoid
the hospital because it
could mean financial
catastrophe.
For 10 years, Sue Riek
suffered from back pain, but
couldn't afford medical
care.
When a mid-life divorce left
her single and without
health insurance, Riek
started a home-business
selling make-up on eBay to
support herself and her two
daughters.
Riek, who lived in
Charlotte, North Carolina,
didn't qualify for Medicaid.
And she couldn't afford a
$5,000 monthly insurance
premium, said her eldest
daughter, Kaytee Riek.
"I don't know if she felt
trapped, but it was a
constant in her life --
struggling outside the
health care system to
exist," her daughter said.
Riek took comfort in her
faith and regularly attended
church. Then one Sunday, she
didn't show up.
The next day, September 3,
2007, her daughter received
the call telling her that
her 51-year-old mother died
from undiagnosed heart
disease -- a condition
treatable with lifestyle
changes, medication and
certain medical procedures.
"I feel incredibly strongly
that she would still be
alive if she had been able
to regularly see a doctor,"
said her daughter.
It has become lethal to be
uninsured, said Woolhandler,
an associate professor of
medicine at Harvard.
"If you can get good primary
care for your high blood
pressure, your high
cholesterol, diabetes --
those don't have to be
lethal conditions," she
said. "If you fail to get
good ongoing primary care,
you may end up with
complications and even
death."
The ranks of the uninsured
have grown, according to the
U.S. Census Bureau. It says
the number of Americans
without health insurance
rose to 46.3 million last
year, up from 45.7 million
in 2007. The percentage of
the uninsured remained at
15.4 percent.
Young adults are more likely
to be uninsured. Elizabeth
Machol, 25, told her mother
she felt tired. She had just
moved into a new apartment
in Santa Rosa, California,
with her boyfriend and
thought the fatigue was from
the move and her cat Bert,
who would keep her up at
night.
Her mother, Marlena Machol
told her to go to the
doctor's office, but Machol
was reluctant. Machol worked
at a movie theater and
didn't have health
insurance. Her parents were
still paying her medical
bills from a previous
condition and she was
worried about the
cost.
A few days after their phone
conversation, Machol
collapsed in the bathroom.
She never regained
consciousness.
One day after her 26th
birthday, Machol was
declared brain dead.
After signing papers to
donate her organs, her
parents kissed her face,
held her hands and said
goodbye to the daughter who
had played the violin,
organized her own fashion
show and taught neighborhood
kids how to swim. The
coroner's office could not
determine the cause of
death.
Six years after her death on
September 22, 2003, her
family wonders if things
would've been different had
she not feared the cost of
going to the hospital.
"Maybe they would've found
out what's wrong," her
mother said. "I don't know
if that would've saved her,
but it would've been a
chance to. There are people
like Elizabeth -- young
people who are starting out
in life and they don't have
options."